Image from Cask
Fort Wayne Sentinel (Fort Wayne, Indiana) Aug 10, 1894
William Coughlin, familiarly known as “Johnny Appleseed,” was sentenced to two years in the penitentiary. A few weeks ago, he stole $50 from Frank Pulver, of Huntertown, and it was on this charge that he was convicted.
Fort Wayne Weekly Gazette (Fort Wayne, Indiana) Nov 12, 1896
William Coughlin, alias, “Johnny Appleseed,” was arrested for drunkenness. He was in a belligerent mood last evening and smashed Officer Romy in the face. Squire France sent him to jail for nineteen days.
The Fort Wayne Sentinel (Fort Wayne, Indiana) Jul 14, 1899
Judge Louttit had easy picking at police court this morning, having only two victims of the night force to spose. “Johnny Appleseed” protested vigorously against being called nicknames in court and insisted that his name is William Coughlin. When asked under that name to enter a plea to a charge of drunkenness, he pleaded guilty.
He says he is no appleseed, nor hayseed either, but is a retired gentleman who drinks at leisure and drinks as often as opportunity affords. The judge told him to take a leisure spell of eleven days and think the matter over.
Jack Case was the other easy mark. Jack was sent over two weeks ago to serve a term for drunkenness. There was another affidavit against him at the time of his first trial for assault and battery on his sister-in-law. On the latter charge he was brought from the jail to police court, and on his plea of guilty was given another eleven days.
The Fort Wayne Sentinel (Fort Wayne, Indiana) Aug 21, 1901
There was a large grist at police court this morning. The venerable Johnny Appleseed, the survivor of more hard fought battles with the booze king than any man in Fort Wayne, made his semi-occasional appearance. Johnny’s return engagement this time was after a shorter interval than usual and he rather hesitatingly admitted to the judge that it had been only ten days since he had faced his honor before.
“But,” said Johnny, in his most persuasive tone, “ef you’ll let me off this time I’ll git right out of town and I’ll niver come back.”
“What do you mean by never?” asked the court. “Niver so long as you’re in office an’ a sittin’ up there.”
Johnny evidently does not know that the judge will be a candidate for re-election in four years, but his story and his promise went with the court.
“I’ll just fine you ten dollars,” said the judge, “and have a mittimus made out for you and the next time the officers catch you in town they’ll take you right over for twenty days, without going to the trouble of bringing you up here. Meantime I will suspend sentence; now do you understand what I mean?”
“I doos, I doos, tank you, tank you!” and Johnny slid out.
The Fort Wayne Sentinel (Fort Wayne, Indiana) Sep 10, 1901
* * * * *
Officer Elliott last night found Johnny Appleseed lying in front of the fire engine house on East Main street. Johnny was in a badly intoxicated condition and the officer took him to headquarters.
The Fort Wayne Journal and Gazette (Fort Wayne, Indiana) Nov 21, 1903
A sure sign of spring showed up yesterday when Johnny Coughlin, familiarly known as “Johnny Appleseed,” blew into the city. It is his wont to remain in the country during the winter and to migrate to the city in the spring. He was given shelter at the police station and, if he follows his usual custom, he will be the occupant of a cell before many days. Johnny is a queer character, of the Sunny Jim type, but his love for drink usually lands him in jail at stated intervals.
The Fort Wayne Journal Gazette (Fort, Wayne, Indiana) Apr 6, 1906
Police headquarters last night got a call that an old soldier was lying drunk in a yard on East Lewis street. Patrolman Elliott responded to the call and found that the supposed soldier was Johnny Coughlin, a police character, who is known as “Johnny Appleseed.”
The officer started Johnny towards his home at the county infirmary and returned to headquarters just in time to investigate a call from Clinton street that an old soldier was lying drunk in a yard.
Going to the place, the officer again found Johnny and decided to take him to the station in order to preserve the reputation of the veterans.
The Fort Wayne Journal Gazette (Fort Wayne, Indiana) May 22, 1907